Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robin Schaufler's avatar

As an active participant in a local Transition Town, and a fan of Rob's earlier books, I expected to love this conversation more than I did. It sounds to me like Rob is building on the fourth landmark in Joanna Macy's spiral journey, but skipping over the first three stages. I think Joanna would say that the first three are necessary to the fruition of the fourth.

Also, you need to think about what the people whom you're starting a story with, and what they do and do not know. Framing is vital.

If I were to invite the public in my hometown to a meeting to imagine the future, about half of them would describe a team sports event, either as a participant or as a spectator.

In fact, my hometown DID do something about the next ten years by updating their Comprehensive Plan. It was a disappointing process in that there was no group visioning, no discussion about the context in which we find ourselves, and no consideration of the costs, present and future, of things people might imagine. A disappointing process yielded a disappointing plan, that might have served well in the 1980s, but now all the development just sounds like more concrete on top of previously living systems.

I hope Rob synthesizes some way of incorporating Reality into the framing of his imagination exercises. In the right context, such as a Work That Reconnects workshop, his sensual narration could be lifechanging for the good.

John Day MD's avatar

Rob Hopkins is a very good man, much ignored...

No posts

Ready for more?